range of tankless water heaters

What To Do When a Water Heater Is Not Heating

Table of Contents

Is your water heater not heating? Being without hot water can be a huge inconvenience. Whether your electric water heater is not heating or your tankless gas system is struggling to function, you'll need the right fix fast. 


In this guide, we'll share some of the most common water heater problems, give you advice on diagnosing these issues and share practical steps for resolution. We'll also give you tips on finding a trusted service provider and how to choose a new system should your existing water heater be beyond repair.

No Hot Water

When you turn on your faucet or shower expecting warm water and you're met with icy cold water, it can be inconvenient and frustrating. The source of the problem could be something relatively simple to fix, such as a tripped circuit breaker, or it could be more complex, like a malfunctioning heating element. 

Common Causes and Fixes

Gas tank water heaters

Tanked Water Heaters

  • Faulty Heating Elements: Leads to inadequate heating. Fix: Test and replace the heating elements if needed.
  • Thermostat Issues: Causes temperature inconsistencies. Fix: replace the thermostat for accurate temperature control.
  • Gas Supply Problems: Prevents burner ignition. Fix: Ensure the gas valve is open and check for supply issues; may require professional assistance.



Tankless Water Heaters

  • Mineral Buildup: Clogs and damages heating elements. Fix: Descale the heater annually, especially in hard water areas.
  • Undersized: Struggles with high demand. Fix: Limit simultaneous hot water use or upgrade to a higher-capacity model.
  • Ignition Failures: Stops the unit from starting. Fix: Check gas supply, venting, and ignition pack; may need professional help.
  • Cold Water Sandwich: Unexpected cold water burst. Fix: Minimize demand fluctuation or consider a model with a built-in buffer tank.
Electric water heaters, tank and tankless

Electric Models

  • Tripped Circuit Breaker: A very common reason for an electric water heater not working is a tripped circuit breaker. Fix: Reset the breaker and check for electrical system overloads.
  • Faulty Heating Elements: Prevents heating. Fix: Replace faulty elements to restore heating efficiency.


Gas Models

  • Vent Blockages: Affects combustion. Fix: Clear the venting system and ensure it's properly installed.

Discolored/Smelly Water

Discolored or smelly water from your hot water heater can be alarming, indicating potential issues within the system. The problem can occur suddenly or build up over time. Below, we list some of the most common causes and straightforward fixes for both tanked and tankless water heaters and provide tips for electric and gas models.


Common Causes and Fixes


  • Bacterial Growth: This leads to smelly water, often described as a "rotten egg" smell. Fix: Flush the system with a solution of water and hydrogen peroxide. For persistent issues, increase the water temperature to 140 degrees F for a short period to kill bacteria, then return to a safer temperature.
  • Deteriorating Sacrificial Anode Rod: When it is consumed, corrosion accelerates Fix: Inspect and replace the anode rod every year or as needed.

Water Heater Is Leaking

Another common reason for a water heater not working is when it has developed a leak. A leaking water heater is a problem that should be addressed immediately to prevent water damage and potential safety hazards. 

electric water heater

Common Causes and Fixes

  • Loose Connections: Fittings or connections may become loose over time. Fix: Tighten any loose fittings or connections with a wrench.
  • Faulty Temperature & Pressure Relief Valve (T&P Valve): If this valve is leaking, it could be due to high pressure or a faulty valve. Fix: Test the valve by lifting the lever and letting it snap back. If it continues leaking, replace the valve. Check water pressure and install a thermal expansion tank. 
  • Leaking Drain Valve: The valve at the bottom of the tank may not be fully closed or could be faulty. Fix: Ensure the drain valve is completely closed. Replace the valve if it continues to leak.
  • Internal Tank Leak: Over time, the tank may corrode and develop a leak. Fix: Unfortunately, if the tank itself is leaking, the entire water heater usually needs to be replaced.
electric heat pump

For Electric Water Heaters

  • Heating Element Gaskets: Leaks can occur around the heating elements if the gaskets fail. Fix: Turn off the power and water supply, drain the tank and replace the gaskets.

For Gas Water Heaters

  • Gas Control Valve Leak: Rare but possible. Fix: This is a job for a professional. If you suspect a leak, turn off the gas supply and call a technician.

Tank Making Strange Sounds

turning the cold water off

Strange sounds coming from a water heater can be disconcerting and often indicate underlying issues. From the buildup of sediment causing loud popping sounds to hissing sounds caused by scale on the heating element, these issues need speedy attention to prevent problems from getting worse. 


Common Causes and Fixes

  • Sediment Buildup: Hard water minerals accumulate at the bottom, causing popping or rumbling noises as the water heats. Fix: Drain and flush the tank to remove sediment. This may need to be done more frequently in areas with hard water.
  • Water Hammer: A sudden stop in water flow can cause loud banging noises, known as water hammer. Fix: Install a water hammer arrestor at the water heater to absorb the shock.
  • Heating Element Scaling: In electric water heaters, scale can form on heating elements, leading to crackling, popping or hissing sounds. Fix: Remove the elements to clean or replace them if heavily coated with scale.
  • T&P Valve Noise: If the temperature and pressure relief valve frequently opens or makes noise, it might indicate high pressure. Fix: Check the home's water pressure and the heater's settings. A pressure-reducing valve or expansion tank may be needed.
solar water heater

Condensation on the Water Heater

Condensation on a water heater can sometimes be mistaken for a leak due to the amount of water it can produce. This phenomenon is particularly common in certain conditions and types of water heaters. 


Common Causes and Fixes

  • High Demand Periods: During times of heavy hot water use, cold water entering the tank can cause the outer surface to cool and condense moisture from the air. Fix: This is usually temporary and resolves as the tank returns to its normal temperature. Ensure adequate ventilation to aid in moisture dissipation.
  • First Use or Refill: Condensation can occur when a new water heater is filled for the first time or after being emptied and refilled due to the difference in temperature between the cold water inside the tank and the warmer external air. Fix: Allow some time for the water heater to reach its operating temperature; condensation should decrease as the tank warms up.
  • High Humidity: In areas with high humidity, condensation is more likely to form on the outside of the tank. Fix: Reducing humidity in the room with a dehumidifier or improving ventilation can help.

Preventive Measures

  • Insulation Blankets: For older tanks, especially in cooler climates or unheated spaces, installing an insulation blanket can help reduce condensation by keeping the outer surface of the tank warmer.
  • Regular Maintenance: Ensure that all components, including vents and flues for gas models, are in good working condition to prevent operational issues that could contribute to condensation.

Damaged Gas Control or Burner Assembly

turning the cold water off

A damaged gas control or burner assembly in a gas water heater can significantly impact its efficiency and safety. Here’s what you need to know about identifying this issue and the steps you can take to resolve it.


Common Causes and Fixes

  • Faulty Gas Control Valve: The gas control valve regulates the gas flow to the burner. A malfunction can lead to inadequate heating or failure to ignite. Fix: This component requires precise calibration and should be inspected and replaced by a professional if found to be defective.
  • Clogged Burner Assembly: Dirt, debris or rust can clog the burner assembly, affecting the flame quality and heating efficiency. Fix: Turn off the gas and water supply, and carefully clean the burner assembly. For heavy buildup or damage, replacement by a professional is recommended.


Damaged Gas Control or Burner Assembly

A damaged gas control or burner assembly in a gas water heater can significantly impact its efficiency and safety. Here’s what you need to know about identifying this issue and the steps you can take to resolve it.


Common Causes and Fixes

  • Faulty Gas Control Valve: The gas control valve regulates the gas flow to the burner. A malfunction can lead to inadequate heating or failure to ignite. Fix: This component requires precise calibration and should be inspected and replaced by a professional if found to be defective.
  • Clogged Burner Assembly: Dirt, debris or rust can clog the burner assembly, affecting the flame quality and heating efficiency. Fix: Turn off the gas and water supply, and carefully clean the burner assembly. For heavy buildup or damage, replacement by a professional is recommended.

Avoid Future Issues With Regular Maintenance

Regular maintenance of your water heater is essential to avoid the raft of potential issues that could lead to inefficiency, safety hazards and costly repairs. Here's a condensed overview of the consequences of neglect and key maintenance tips.


Consequences of Neglect

  • Reduced Efficiency: Sediment buildup reduces heating efficiency, increasing energy costs.
  • Premature Failure: Corrosion and sediment can shorten the lifespan of the heater, leading to early replacement needs.
  • Safety Risks: For gas heaters, poor maintenance can result in dangerous carbon monoxide production or fire hazards due to faulty gas connections.
  • Water Quality Issues: bacterial growth, affecting water safety and can cause smells.
  • Leak Risks: Increased risk of leaks and water damage from corrosion and sediment pressure.

Essential Maintenance Tips

  • Annual Tank Flush: Removes sediment to maintain efficiency.
  • Anode Rod Inspection/Replacement: Every year to prevent corrosion.
  • Pressure Relief Valve Check: Ensures safety by preventing excessive pressure buildup.
  • Gas Heater Checks: Include venting and gas line inspections for safety.
  • Leak Inspections: Regularly check for signs of leaks or damage.

Regular maintenance helps extend the life of your water heater, keeps it running efficiently and ensures safe operation, saving you money and hassle in the long run. Learn more about Water Heater Maintenance.

Water Heater Fixes With A. O Smith

Understanding that water heater issues can be a source of significant inconvenience, A. O. Smith offers an extensive array of resources aimed at demystifying water heater repairs for the average homeowner. From finding replacement parts to locating product resources by model, you'll find a wealth of helpful tools and resources on our website. Not sure where to start troubleshooting your system or feeling out of your depth? Find an A. O. Smith trusted service provider for a professional opinion.

Want to Upgrade Your Water Heater?

There are times when a hot water heater not working calls for a replacement or upgrade. At A. O. Smith, we make choosing a hot water heater easier with our Water Heater Selector Tool. You can also search our directory of authorized, local professionals to install your new water heater for you. 

Problems With Your Water Heater?

Are you experiencing issues with your water heater? Whether it's a lack of hot water, strange noises or any other fault, you don't have to tackle these challenges alone. A reliable solution is just a click away. 


Visit our directory of trusted providers to find a local expert who can diagnose and solve your water heater problems efficiently. With access to a network of certified professionals, you're sure to find the support you need to get your water heating system back to optimal performance. Don't let water heater troubles disrupt your day — help is closer than you think.

Learn About Tankless Water Heaters

There are times when a hot water heater not working calls for a replacement or upgrade. At A. O. Smith, we make choosing a hot water heater easier with our Water Heater Selector Tool. You can also search our directory of authorized, local professionals to install your new water heater for you.

Electric Tankless Water Heaters

Electric tankless water heaters are celebrated for their compact size and lower initial installation cost. Ideal for smaller households or point-of-use applications, they run on electricity, making them a great choice for homes without natural gas service. These units are highly efficient, as they convert almost all the energy they consume into hot water, reducing energy waste.

Gas Tankless Water Heaters

Gas tankless water heaters on the other hand, are suited for larger households with higher hot water demands. They typically offer higher flow rates than their electric counterparts and can be more cost-effective to operate in the long run, especially in regions where gas is cheaper than electricity. These units require venting to the outdoors but are an excellent choice for families looking to maximize hot water usage without sacrificing space or efficiency.